Further to our recent post Safeguarding: St Andrew’s Chorleywood, (29 July 2026), the Church of England summary of its safeguarding Reviews and Reports links is reproduced below; the index to L&RUK posts on safeguarding and “lessons learnt” reviews may be found here.
Reviews and reports
A new comprehensive policy (Code) on safeguarding practice reviews (SPR), previously called lessons learned reviews, was approved by General Synod in July 2023. The policy is clear that reflective learning by Church bodies in respect of safeguarding can take different forms. When a situation demands a more formal approach with an independent dimension, a SPR will be commissioned. It is expected these cases will be in the minority.
Recommendations and themes from reviews and reports, (25/04/2024).
The recommendations from the Church’s reviews into Bishop Victor Whitsey, Graham Gregory, William Scott Farrell, and Trevor Devamanikkam, along with two reports from the Independent Safeguarding Board, ISB, Don’t Panic Be Pastoral and Mr X have been analysed and grouped into themes
Separately the recent reports and recommendations from barrister Sarah Wilkinson and former IICSA chair Professor Alexis Jay are being looked at by a Response Group.
The information below provides an overview of how the themes identified are being addressed and incorporated into the Safeguarding work of the National Safeguarding Team NST, and wider Safeguarding practice across the Church of England, in policy reviews, learning and development programmes and projects.
- Responding well to disclosures of abuse – The Responding Well to Victim and Survivors policy has been in place since November 2021 and covers significant aspects of the recommendations in this category. The Managing Allegations policy which is currently in the final phase and is due to be taken to July General Synod for consideration, addresses the remaining recommendations in this category.
- Managing allegations, core group process – the Managing Allegations policy discussed above addresses this recommendation. The Safeguarding Standards support good practice for case work. Case reviews are part of the Quality Assurance Framework and Independent Audits.
- Records keeping, retention of records and sharing of information – there are several projects ongoing which address the issues raised in this theme: Implementation of the NSCMS, Managing Allegations policy, Responding Well to Victims and Survivor policy, Data Service Retention policy review, Information Sharing agreements in place across the Church and with the police.
- Supervision, audits and Independent oversight – the recommendations in this theme are addressed by the IICSA 1 and 8 project, in relation to the DSA to DSO change and providing professional supervision to DSO’s, Quality Assurance and Independent Audits, independent oversight is one of the recommendations from Professor Jay which the Church is currently responding to.
- Learning and development – there are several recommendations that relate to safeguarding training and the revised version of the Learning and Development framework has been approved by the National Safeguarding Steering Group and is going to July General Synod.
- Policy – the Learning development team have a programme of reviewing the current policies and the recommendations will be incorporated into these reviews.
- Civil Claims – EIG have significantly changed their practices pre IICSA and regularly refresh their Guiding Principles which includes apologies.
- Safer Recruitment – these recommendations are covered by the Safer Recruitment policy which has been in place since June 2021 and will be evaluated during 2024.
- Commissioning of Learning Lessons Reviews – these recommendations are covered by the Safeguarding Practice Review policy approved by July 2023 General Synod.
The recommendations are reviewed on a regular basis to ensure that they are being incorporated into the work of the NST and disseminated for operational delivery in Diocese and Cathedrals.
Ongoing independent reviews and audits
- Independent Safeguarding Audit Programme of dioceses and cathedrals
- Christ Church, Oxford: A review of the handling of alleged safeguarding issues regarding the former Dean of Christ Church, Oxford, Dr Martyn Percy. This review is currently suspended.
- David Tudor Review: a Safeguarding Practice Review jointly commissioned by the National Safeguarding Team and the dioceses of Chelmsford and Southwark to look at the lessons to be learnt from the Church’s handling of the David Tudor case.
Completed reviews and reports
- TT review: An independent review, commissioned from thirtyone:eight, of the Church’s handling of case TT, focusing on the response to allegations of rape, sexual abuse and spiritual abuse by two clergy youth officers (July 2026)
- John Smyth review: An independent review, by Keith Makin, of the Church’s handlings of allegations against the late John Smyth (Nov 2024).
- Soul Survivor review from Fiona Scolding KC (Sept 20)
- Future of Church Safeguarding report from Professor Jay (Feb 2024).
- Independent report from barrister Sarah Wilkinson into the ISB (Nov 2023).
- Independent Safeguarding Board, ISB, case study and response (June 2023).
- Trevor Devamanikkam review: A review of the Church’s handling of allegations against the late priest relating to sexual abuse of a 16 year old in 1984 and later disclosures to senior figures (May 2023).
- 2019-21 diocesan safeguarding data (Feb 2023).
- Past Cases Review 2 – run in all Church of England dioceses 2019-2022
- Don’t Panic Be Pastoral: ISB report into experiences of victims & survivors (2022)
- Fr Alan Griffin review (2022): The Diocese of London published an independent review into the handling of allegations described by Coroner Mary Hassell in her Regulation 28 Report (July 2021) to the Church of England in relation to the death by suicide of Fr Alan Griffin.
- William Scott Farrell (2022): An independent overview report of his recruitment and appointment at three cathedrals (he was convicted of sexual offences while employed in two, with concerns raised at a third)
- Graham Gregory review (2022): A lessons learnt review into the handling of allegations in five dioceses relating to the deceased priest.
- Bishop Whitsey review: A Betrayal of Trust (2020), the independent report into the Church’s handling of the allegations concerning the late Hubert Victor Whitsey, former Bishop of Chester.
- Independent Review into Church’s handling of Bishop George Bell case (2017) and annexes to the review.
- NSSG response to Carlile Review recommendations
- An Abuse of Faith (2017): An independent review by Dame Moira Gibb into the Church’s handling of the late Bishop Peter Ball case.
- NSSG response to Gibb Review recommendations
- Kendall House review (July 2016) and Kendall House Review update
- Elliott Review findings and response from Bishop Sarah Mullally (2016)
Other key reports
- SCIE Final overview report of the independent diocesan safeguarding audits and additional work on improving responses to survivors of abuse (2019)
- NSSG Response to SCIE Overview Report
- A review of the implementation of the the Church of England safeguarding training and development framework (2018)
- NST Response to the Review of the Implementation of the Church of England Safeguarding Training and Development Framework Report
- Safeguarding Data Report 2018
- Safeguarding Data Report 2015-2017
- Independent Scrutiny Report on the CofE’s Original PCR (2018)
- National Safeguarding Summit 2017 Report
- Second overview report on independent audits and National Safeguarding Team response and action plan (2017)
- Report from the National Safeguarding Panel (2016)