Ecclesiastical and other court determinations – October 2026

Review of the ecclesiastical court judgments during October

Summaries to the 9 consistory court judgments reviewed during October are listed below, with links to the L&RUK review. These included [*]:

 

This review also includes: CDM Decisions and Safeguarding; Privy Council Business; CFCE Determinations; and Links to other L&RUK posts relating to ecclesiastical law.

An index to these and earlier judgments in here.


Reordering, extensions and other building works

Substantial reordering

Re St. Swithun East Retford [2025] ECC S&N 5 The Chancellor of the Diocese considered a major reordering of the Grade II* listed church, including removal of pews, a raised heated floor, new toilets and servery, chairs, carpeting, AV equipment and lighting. The listing refers to the features and history including: ‘ [a] fine set of priests’ and choir stalls, and also fine set of pews in nave and aisles’. However, the church is on the Historic England ‘Heritage at Risk’ register; [i]ts condition is recorded as ‘poor’ and priority A: ‘immediate risk of further rapid deterioration or loss of fabric; no solution agreed’ [5].

Ockelton noted (at [6]): “[t]he role of St Swithun’s in the life of its people and in the life of Retford is not what it has been in the past, even the recent past. I need to try and assess how the church works today in order to have some context for the proposals, and in order, amongst other things, in due course to assess the extent to which changes to the church are justified”.

Until the arrival of the present incumbent, who was licenced in September 2022, there had been an interregnum lasting about five years, with cover provided mostly by retired clergy[7]. Since then the pattern has changed. The Thursday services continue, and have roughly the same numbers; it is said that there are ‘new visitors to the services every week’, but the figures do suggest that if that is the case there is a turnover, with the new visitors replacing some who are not attending[8]. However, he noted:

“[9, 10] There are many difficulties in trying to derive facts from these figures. The collection figures say nothing about regular giving; and there is no information on the extent to which the congregation is Retford-based…the exterior of the church is forbidding. The present worshipping community do not find it possible to open the church except when an activity is taking place inside. The fact that the impressive main church of a relatively populous community is not favoured for weddings is a matter of note”.

In the assessment of the Chancellor [emphasis added]:

“[11] …although there are many good things happening at St Swithun’s at the moment, and under the current leadership, the church cannot really be described as an asset to the general community. It does not appear to be lively except to those who are already involved with it; it is not readily available to members of the community as a whole, and research on-line would be unlikely to lead to finding out what the congregation is really doing. At the moment, the main body of the church is used for some meetings, for worship for about 90 minutes a week, and for fellowship before and afterwards;…The needs to be addressed are in realistic terms limited to those of the present worshipping community, not those of Retford as a whole.”

The proposals were prepared by Aaron Walker of AWA Building Consultancy, [12,13] were supported by a statement of significance by Mr James Edgar; this included a gazetteer listing the old features of the church affected by the proposals, and assessing their individual significance, [14] to [16]. The DAC sought comment from Historic England (HE), Historic Buildings and Places (HBAP, but called ‘Antiquities Society’ by the architect), and the Victorian Society (VicSoc), [17] to [21], to which there was a response form the parish, although no details were given about the heating, but the details of the floor were part of a section called ‘Underfloor heating comments’ [22].

The DAC’s notification of advice was that it did not object to the work being approved by this court. It said, in the form permitted by the Rules, that the parish’s explanation of the way in which it had had regard to the net zero guidance was adequate.

Applying the Duffield test, the Chancellor found that raising the floor would cause serious harm to the church’s architectural and historic significance, particularly by concealing the bases of the piers and replacing the historic floor with modern materials. The proposed heating system was inadequately justified and lacked sufficient technical, cost and net-zero analysis. Removal of most pews was permitted because the resulting flexibility and community benefit outweighed the lesser heritage harm. However, the proposed metal-framed upholstered chairs, extensive carpeting and west-end servery were rejected because less damaging alternatives existed and the justification was insufficient.

Faculty was therefore granted only for specified pew removals, wooden stackable chairs, subject to approval, relocating the organ console, and new WCs and water heater. The remaining proposals were refused, principally for inadequate detail or justification. [Re St. Swithun East Retford [2025] ECC S&N 5] [Top of section] [Top of post].

Removal and replacement of pews

Re St. Helen Thorganby [2026] ECC Yor 2 The petition sought approval for the permanent removal of five pews from the Grade I listed church. The pews had been temporarily removed under a temporary minor reordering licence, (“TMRO”), creating a flexible space for hospitality, informal worship, Bible study and community activities[2]. The trial demonstrated that the space was well used and improved accessibility and social interaction[3]. Eight objections were received, principally concerning the loss of the church’s traditional appearance, seating capacity and the perceived need for hospitality space.

One of the objectors did not qualify as an “interested person” within the definition provided by rule 10.1(1) FJR (living in London, having. not lived in the parish for many years, and lacking any sufficient qualifying interest in the subject matter of the petition.) And finally, with a couple of notable exceptions, the majority of the letters appear to follow a loose template in their content and mode of expression. “Although not ideal, this does not disqualify or indeed necessarily weaken the strength of the objection expressed. However, in this case, somewhat concerningly, that template appears to have been founded upon either a failure to properly read the scope of work proposed by the Petition or otherwise a serious misunderstanding of it[5].

The DAC considered the petition and recommended it to me in their Notification of Advice (the “NoA”), dated 9 June 2026, without any comment or proviso[8]. She noted:

“[11]. The pews (i.e. the whole collection of eighteen pews which fill the nave and to the west of the entrance door (the “Nave Pews), which includes the five Pews which are the subject of this Petition, plus the two choir pews (the “Choir Pews”) in the chancel) are not identified in the listing entry as being of particular significance…

[12]. …the two Choir Pews in the chancel are deserving of separate consideration as they are the best of the benches in the building. They should, in my view, be evaluated in common with the prie-dieu, altar rails and nave lectern, with which the Choir Pew frontals match and these are all well-made Victorian pieces with a distinct appearance and style.

[13]. The Nave Pews (including the five removed Pews) which are the focus of attention in this judgment, are different in character and quality…

[14]. It is important to recognise the contribution the Pews as a whole make to the “plain” impression of the interior, in spite of the fact that they are not picked out as being particularly noteworthy in and of themselves, nor is their collective contribution deemed sufficiently important to warrant mention in the listing entry…

[15]. That does not, however, mean that the pewed interior must remain preserved as it is and unchanged forever. It does mean that it is important to evaluate its contribution to the overall significance of the church and to take proper consideration of it in proposals for relevant changes

de Mestre Ch. concluded:

“[34]. … that there is no harm to significance by the proposal before me and that the evidence in support of the Petition, even taking into consideration the matters raised in the qualifying letters of objection, is convincing and provides sound reasons for making permanent the removal of the Pews sufficient to rebut any presumption in favour of retaining the status quo. I am supported in reaching those conclusions by the evidence before me and by the success of the temporary reordering under the TMRO  which has allowed many of the ideas regarding flexibility, space and accessibility to be experimented with.

The outcomes have confirmed that the space is put to a much greater variety of uses without the Pews than when they were present and that the ability of the church to seat large congregations, even when filled at well-attended special services, has not been compromised.

 A faculty was granted without conditions[36]. [Re St. Helen Thorganby [2026] ECC Yor 2] [Top of section] [Top of post]


Net zero issues

Re St. Mary Magdalene Stoke Bishop [2025] ECC Bri 4

On 13 October 2025 a petition passed the seal for a reordering of this Grade II listed church. One part of the petition was for the replacement of the existing gas fired boiler with air source heat pumps. No objections were received. The DAC and PCC were both unanimous in their support for it, and so it passed the seal with two conditions; a). All the works were to be carried out under the supervision of the appointed architect; and b). All the works were to be carried out in accordance with the planning permission dated 21/03/25, with minor amendments to incorporate DAC comments[1].

The local authority, having raised concerns about the noise levels that would be generated by the 14kW air pumps, were considering granting planning permission for the installation of air pumps but  stipulated that the 14kW air pumps be replaced with smaller 10kW air pumps[4].

Neighbour complained that even the newer, smaller pumps would be too noisy to be installed and as they say with firmness but courtesy, they would go to law to stop the installation of any such pumps. One of the neighbours also raises, with dignified restraint, the health of a member of their family which would be adversely affected by the noise. That neighbour also states that they are ‘willing to consider contributing to’ any extra costs associated with the installation of a gas boiler [6].

The parish priest has also raised the point that the threat of litigation has caused her considerable stress and that this may further affect her ministry in the future if litigation were to happen and the attendant stress increase [7].

Gau Ch. noted that it was very clear “that the parish had due regard to the Church of England’s net zero guidance as required by the Faculty Jurisdiction Rules. Indeed, that is clear from the very full advice that they received and which formed part of their petition. It was from that advice that they decided that air pumps were the best possible solution to improve the heating and to conform to the Church’s guidance” [8].

The DAC were initially sceptical about agreeing to the proposed amendment, although After some investigation that stance changed. At the meeting on Thursday 16 October 2025, the DAC resolved to recommend this application to the Chancellor. The DAC sympathised greatly with the parish, but was concerned to reach a clear, evidence-based decision. The Chancellor stated:

[9]…The Committee did not reach its conclusions lightly but was nonetheless resolute in that a) the parish has shown due regard to the published guidance on climate change, b). the setting of the church is, outside of ‘active’ times, exceptionally quiet despite being highly populated, c). the parish is striving to achieve the compelling mission benefits of the project as a whole and the specific mission objective of responding to climate change – and that the revised proposals are achieving the best balance of mission outcomes at this point and d). there is a commitment to working with the DAC/Diocese to progress towards net zero. They therefore recommend this proposal to the Chancellor.”

The Chancellor concluded:

“[14]. In summary I take into account the unique set of circumstances here:
a). the exceptionally quiet environment in a suburban area which would be unusually affected by even the smaller of the air pumps being used 24 hours a day; b). the particular medical consequences of the noise in this case; c). the effect that the threatened litigation would have on the viability of this church’s mission; d).the effect of the stress of the threatened litigation on the incumbent.

[15]. I am prepared to allow the suggested amendment and, contrary to the Church of England’s guidance on achieving net zero, allow the replacement of this gas boiler with another one.

[16]. I would encourage both the petitioners and the opponent neighbours to consider making some material contribution to net zero initiatives.

The ELA review comments “the judgment demonstrates that environmental guidance must be carefully weighed against local circumstances, health concerns and the practical consequences for a church’s mission, without establishing a general exception to the Church’s net-zero policy”. [Re St. Mary Magdalene Stoke Bishop [2025] ECC Bri 4]  [Top of post].


Exhumation

Errors in burial

Re Kensal Green Cemetery [2026] ECC Lon 2 A faculty was granted to LL to exhume his late father AL’s remains from a mausoleum at Kensal Green Cemetery for cremation and repatriation to Italy, where they would be reunited with the remains of his wife. The court applied the principle in Blagdon Cemetery that burial in consecrated ground is permanent and final, subject to exceptional circumstances.

On the balance of probabilities, the Chancellor accepted that LL had not been informed that the mausoleum stood on consecrated ground, or of the legal consequences, when his father was entombed in 1986. LL alleged that he had told the Cemetery authority that the placing of his father’s remains in the mausoleum was intended to be temporary and he had not be advised of any possible difficulties relating to subsequent removal of the remains. This lack of knowledge constituted the exceptional circumstance displacing the presumption of permanence.

Although two siblings opposed the application, the court concluded that LL had principally assumed responsibility for his parents’ funeral arrangements and that his mother had wished for the couple’s remains to be reunited in Italy. The faculty was granted subject to conditions governing the exhumation, cremation and repatriation, including compliance with prescribed procedures. [Re Kensal Green Cemetery [2026] ECC Lon 2] [Top of section] [Top of post]. Note: this is a lengthy judgment [26pp]. 


Churchyards and burials

Designation of closed churchyard

See Privy Council Business.

Churchyard Regulations

Re St. Giles Croxden [2026] ECC Lic 1 Petition sought a memorial which was to include kerbs and chippings sought in respect of a young man tragically killed at the age of just 32. The petition was supported by the Parochial Church Council, but opposed by the Diocesan Advisory Committee. There were some other examples of kerbed memorials in the Churchyard, but none were recent and only one at the back of the Church (the area of the grave in question). The judgment reviews the last decade of case law and examines the varying reasons given for prohibiting kerbs. In the end, despite the tragedy of the case, a faculty was refused in respect of the kerbs and chippings on the basis that the proposed memorial would jar with the open and rural setting of the Churchyard. [Re St. Giles Croxden [2026] ECC Lic 1] [Top of section] [Top of post].

Re Holy Cross Woodchurch [2026] ECC Chr 1 A faculty was granted permitting the reinstatement of kerbstones and stone chippings around the grave of DH and RH. The kerbstones and chippings had been installed approximately 13 years earlier, purportedly with permission from a previous incumbent who lacked authority to approve them. They were removed to facilitate the interment of RH’s ashes. Her children subsequently sought permission to restore the kerbs and chippings. Under the Chester Diocesan Churchyard Regulations 2007, kerbstones and grave chippings are prohibited without a faculty. The Chancellor considered an earlier judgment concerning the same churchyard, which emphasised the need for consistency and good reasons to justify departures from the regulations. The Chancellor found that exceptional circumstances existed: the memorial had been in place for many years, and both RH and her children reasonably believed it was lawfully authorised. The petitioners were therefore not at fault. These factors collectively constituted compelling grounds for granting the faculty, notwithstanding the general prohibition. [Re Holy Cross Woodchurch [2026] ECC Chr 1] [Top of section] [Top of post]

Re St. Helen Benson [2026] ECC Oxf 14 The Chancellor of the Diocese considered an application for a faculty to install a memorial to the petitioner’s late husband, John, in a historic churchyard. The disputed element of the petition concerned the proposed inscription, particularly the familial terms “Dad” and “Grampy”, prohibited by recently introduced supplemental regulations requiring formal descriptions of family relationships. The Rector, Parochial Church Council and Diocesan Advisory Committee opposed the application. Objections also arose from the family of a neighbouring deceased person, whose relatives had previously been required to comply with the same restrictions.

Applying the merits-based approach in Re St Giles, Exhall [2021] EACC 1, the Chancellor held that non-compliance with churchyard regulations does not automatically justify refusal; each application must be assessed on its merits. He granted the faculty, permitting the informal familial terms out of compassion for the bereaved family and because they accurately reflected the deceased’s identity within his family. The Chancellor emphasised that this exceptional decision created no precedent for future burials. [Re St. Helen Benson [2026] ECC Oxf 14] [Top of section] [Top of post].

Reservation of grave space

Re St. Mary Magdalene Greenham [2026] ECC Oxf 15 KD wished to reserve a double-depth grave for herself and her husband, and their son CD wished to reserve an adjoining grave for himself and his brother, both of them disabled adults. The family had longstanding connections with the parish, with several generations buried in the churchyard. Both sons’ disabilities and reliance on their parents made remaining together particularly important. The family had also reasonably believed the plots were already reserved, but the parish had failed to complete the necessary paperwork. The incumbent, churchwardens and Parochial Church Council supported both petitions. However, with less than five years’ burial capacity remaining, the Chancellor applied the principles in Re St. Mary Thame [2022] ECC Oxf 2. Reservations exceeding the churchyard’s remaining capacity require exceptional circumstances. Despite expressing considerable sympathy, he concluded that the family’s circumstances did not meet this threshold. The parish’s administrative error could not override the burial rights of other parishioners. The Chancellor decided that KD’s petition should granted for five years, with permission to apply for a further 20-year extension during the final year. CD’s petition was dismissed. The Chancellor noted that future churchyard reordering might provide additional burial capacity. [Re St. Mary Magdalene Greenham [2026] ECC Oxf 15] [Top of section] [Top of page].


Bells

Re St. John the Baptist Stamford Bridge [2026] ECC Yor 1 A faculty was granted for remedial works to the chiming bells at St. John the Baptist, Stamford Bridge, an unlisted Victorian church. The two 1867 bells and their fittings were unsafe and had deteriorated.

The Diocesan Advisory Committee (DAC) Bells Adviser suggested they were cast  either whilst the church was in the planning stage and installed in 1867, or they were stock bells; he acknowledged that they are not listed by the Church Buildings Council (CBC) as “worthy of preservation” although Murray Dep. Ch. noted that the CBC Code for the Conservation and Repair of Bells and Bellframes 2007 (the CBC Code) itself indicates this does not imply that such bells were not worthy of preservation[2].

Although the bells lacked particular historic significance, their traditional mechanical chiming had important local and communal value. The PCC emphasised the community importance of maintaining manual chiming, noting that fundraising was expressly tied to preserving that function. While the bells are not historically significant, their role in village identity and worship gives them local communal significance, justifying careful reinstatement[3].

However, the bells and fittings are now unsafe and heavily weathered. The DAC Bells Adviser noted “deteriorated wooden headstocks, worn wheels, ferrous gudgeon plates damaging the stonework, and an ageing wire-and-crank chiming system that is difficult and unsafe to maintain. Together, these factors demonstrate a clear need for removal, refurbishment and rehanging with reliable fittings”[4]. The Petitioners sought a faculty:

“[5]. To remove the bells and headstocks from the bell turret, remove the cannons [sic], fit two new galvanised headstocks, a galvanised lever, wall mounted bearing brackets, clapper assemblies, galvanised sally guide wire and bronze pulleys and new bell chiming ropes, and reinstall the bells with new fittings as per the Proposal from Pembletons Bellhangers and Engineers dated 30th April 2026”.

There were 3 areas of disagreement between the Petitioners and the DAC Bells Adviser, the first two being the most significant. These essentially technical issues were analysed at:

  • Removal of canons, [10] to [17];
  • The headstocks, [18] to [23]; and
  • Mechanical versus electromagnetic chiming, [24,25].

Having regard to the judgment in St John the Evangelist, Cononley with Bradley and to the CBC Code, which specifically advised against the removal of canons, as a general principle, the Chancellor was not persuaded there was sufficient justification for their removal (CBC Code and Re St. John the Evangelist Cononley with Bradley [2020] ECC Lee 1 cited).

The proposal for new galvanised steel headstocks was approved; despite the conservation preference for traditional hardwood, the court accepted the durability, low maintenance and environmental arguments for steel, subject to approval of the paint finish. Mechanical chiming (as opposed to electromagnetic chiming) was approved, because preserving the established tradition was important to the community, which had specifically funded its continuation.

A faculty passed the seal for the proposed bell-work on the basis that the canons were retained. No authority was granted for their removal and the faculty was subject to the conditions set out in the Annex, [26]. [Re St. John the Baptist Stamford Bridge [2026] ECC Yor 1]


Privy Council Business

14 October 2026

Burial Act 1853 (Notice)
An Order giving notice of the discontinuance of burials in:—

  • St Mary’s Churchyard, Stow, Lincoln, Lincolnshire;
  • St Peter’s Church Churchyard (Old Part Only), Allendale, Northumberland;
  • St James’s Church Churchyard, Murton, York, North Yorkshire;
  • St John the Evangelist Churchyard (Part Closure), Lepton, Huddersfield, West Yorkshire;
  • St Peter’s Church Churchyard, Cowleigh Bank, Malvern, Worcestershire.

Burial Act 1853 (Final)
An Order prohibiting further burials in:-

  • St Mary’s Churchyard and Burial Ground, Elloughton, East Riding of Yorkshire;
  • St Mary the Virgin Churchyard, Denby Village, Ripley, Derbyshire;
  • St John’s Church Churchyard, Throapham, Sheffield, South
    Yorkshire.

Burial Act 1855 (Variation)

  • An Order varying an Order dated 26th June 1996 prohibiting further burials in the Churchyard of St Martin of Tours, Exminster, Devon.

CDM Decisions and Safeguarding

Written determinations of disciplinary tribunals hearing complaints brought under the CDM, together with any decisions on penalty are published by the Church of England; included are judgments from the Arches Court of Canterbury and the Chancery Court of York where determinations have been appealed. The majority of complaints that are made under the CDM are resolved by the bishop, archbishop, or President of Tribunals, without having to convene a tribunal.

CDM Decisions

Penalties by consent

The page on the CofE website Penalties by Consent records the penalties that have been imposed by a bishop or archbishop with the consent of the respondent under section 16 of the Clergy Discipline Measure 2003 and penalties that have been imposed under section 30 or 31.

Name: The Revd DANIEL DAVID INMAN
Diocese: London
Date imposed: 1st October 2026
Relevant CDM section: 16(1)
Statutory Ground of Misconduct: 8(1)(d) conduct unbecoming or inappropriate to the office and work of a clerk in Holy Orders
Penalty: Limited Prohibition for 3 years

Name: The Revd SONYA MARSHALL 
Diocese: Liverpool
Date imposed: 29th September 2026
Relevant CDM section: 16(1)
Statutory Ground of Misconduct: 8 (1)(c) Neglect or inefficiency in the performance of the duties of her office
Penalty: Rebuke and injunction (with effect from 1st October 2026)

Name: The Revd MICHAEL FOX
Diocese: Norwich
Date imposed: 23rd September 2026
Relevant CDM section: 16(1)
Statutory Ground of Misconduct: 8(1)(d) conduct unbecoming or inappropriate to the office and work of a clerk in Holy Orders
Penalty: Limited Prohibition for 3 years

Name: The Revd PAUL PHILIP PATERSON 
Diocese: Durham
Date Imposed: 20th September 2026
Relevant CDM Section: 16(1)
Statutory Ground of Misconduct: 8(1)(d) conduct unbecoming or inappropriate to the office and work of a clerk in Holy Orders
Penalty: Prohibition for three years and Injunction (with effect from 7th October 2026

Safeguarding

Statement from Bishop of Sheffield following the retrial of Chris Brain: On 2 October 2026, Chris Brain was found guilty on all remaining charges, following a retrial on the five charges the jury could not agree on in his original trial in 2025. Brain was convicted in August 2025 of 17 counts of indecent assault against nine women who were members of the Nine O’Clock Service in Sheffield. This retrial concerned the charge of rape, and four further counts of indecent assault, on which the original jury could not reach a verdict.

The Bishop of Sheffield, Dr Pete Wilcox, said: “Last year I…commissioned an independent Safeguarding Practice Review into how the Church responded at the time. We took the decision to delay that review until these outstanding charges had been resolved, so as not to cut across the retrial. With today’s verdict, that review will now begin, and I remain committed to seeing it through, and to acting on its findings.” (2 October 2026).

Scottish Episcopal  Church: Statement regarding the Diocese of Aberdeen & Orkney. The Preliminary Proceedings Committee of the Scottish Episcopal Church has referred a complaint concerning the Rt Rev Anne Dyer, Bishop of Aberdeen & Orkney, to the Church’s Procurator under Canon 54, the Church’s clergy discipline canon (14 October 2026).


CFCE Determinations

The dates of the Cathedrals Fabric Commission for England may be found by scrolling down to the bottom of the page Cathedrals Fabric Commission.  The programme for 2026 is here and the next meeting will be on Thursday 22 October 2025.


Links to other posts

Recent summaries of specific issues that have been considered in the consistory courts include:

General/Miscellaneous

[Top]

Updated: 31 September 2026 at 12:45. 


[*] This is an approximate classification based upon the  main issues considered by the court. Determinations relating to reordering and building works will often address other aspects of the Petition.

Notes on the conventions used for the navigation between cases reviewed in this post are summarized here.

Cite this article as: David Pocklington, "Ecclesiastical and other court determinations – October 2026" in Law & Religion UK, 31 October 2026, https://lawandreligionuk.com/2026/10/31/ecclesiastical-and-other-court-determinations-october-2026/

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *